Guest viewing is limited

Japanese Women & Close-minded Or Racist Interference

Solong

TAG Member
Joined
Jan 18, 2013
Messages
2,502
Reaction score
2,199
Many Japanese women don't give international dating a try, due to very negative advice or stories told by cowardly, close-minded, or racist Japanese friends or associates who scare or intimidate them. NOT all Japanese are like that, but some are.

For example, she tells her girlfriend of meeting a foreign person, and then her friend tells her some horrible story about foreigners or the area she met him; often from the Japanese news. The story or about the location, can have nothing to do with the foreign guy whatsoever. However, it's sufficient to scare her friend. Opportunity in life lost. And for many Japanese, their bubble is small, and they rarely get out of it.

Basically the friend is cowardly or racist, and is pushing or forcing their beliefs on other friends. I've seen this behavior extend to even Japanese who don't know each other. They pretend they are "protecting" them, and instead are being assholish xenophobics or racists. There is no "protection", just lots of close-mindedness or cowardice.

For example. Was with a date in Shimbashi. I'm not so familiar with the area, but she wanted to drink there. I choose a random bar, that looked interesting from the outside and I have never been to before.

After a short while, the older bartender there tries to test my level of Japanese. I pretend I don't speak Japanese, and also because I'm trying to focus on my date and talk with her instead.

The bartender, thinking I don't speak Japanese and using the opportunity of me going to the bathroom, then begins to tell the Japanese woman I'm with, all kinds of really fucked up lies. Like I'm a playboy that comes to the bar all the time (never been there in my life), and she should be careful of me.

My Japanese date of course doesn't know what the hell is going and is trying to be respectful to this older guy. Another Japanese woman, who seemed also upset by what the bartender is doing, informs me a bit about what was said while I was in the bathroom. The other woman had spent 10 years in California, and just returned to Japan. She asks me if I've ever came to the bar before. In the 3-way conversation, in Japanese, I figure out what was going on, and primarily because the other Japanese woman recently from the U.S. decided to air out what happened.

I then get pissed off about the insanity that was spewed by the bartender. Me and the asshole bartender then get into an argument. My Japanese date decides to run out. Likely embarrassed or afraid of the situation. I didn't bother to chase after her, and instead finished telling the bartender about how wrong it is to do the bullshit he pulled. Totally no reason to do that, and I was a customer.

A lot of foreigners in Japan have no idea about the very negative stories and underhanded tactics being used to scare Japanese women.
 
Last edited:
Maybe the bartender was a TAG member, looking to poke the bear. ;)
 
@Solong Your bar story sucks man. But do you think this guy was a douche because he was Japanese, or because he was just a douche human being?

I think you could replace the Japan in your post with many other countries in the world and it would still be valid. Xenophobia is worldwide.

The other thing I got from your post was how awesome it was that the other Japanese woman got upset at what he was doing and actually did something to help you out.

I think we need to be careful about is labeling everything that goes wrong in our lives in Japan as racist or cowardly. In my experience a lot is also ignorance (which I'm not excusing) or apathy.
 
@Solong Your bar story sucks man. But do you think this guy was a douche because he was Japanese, or because he was just a douche human being?

I think you could replace the Japan in your post with many other countries in the world and it would still be valid. Xenophobia is worldwide.

The other thing I got from your post was how awesome it was that the other Japanese woman got upset at what he was doing and actually did something to help you out.

I think we need to be careful about is labeling everything that goes wrong in our lives in Japan as racist or cowardly. In my experience a lot is also ignorance (which I'm not excusing) or apathy.
I've traveled to other countries in Asia and Europe. It can also be a problem in various Asian countries, but it takes a different form. You can meet douche bags anywhere, but not on this sly backstabbing type of level, that's prevalent in Japan. In other places, it's more primitive and backwards male territorial behavior. In America and Europe, people call it out for what it is; racism. And most people know better and respect the rights of other people. They would just leave an international or interracial couple alone.

The tactic of backstabbing or making friends fear foreigners is something more prevalent in Japan, due to xenophobia. It's not an isolated incident, but something close-minded or racist Japanese engage in a lot. They pretend to be "protecting" others, but instead are imposing their very paranoid, negative, and racist beliefs on others. Such xenophobic behavior is wrong, whether in Japan or other countries. Because it's an attack on human beings to freely associate with who they choose.

It's partially also why the English speaking ability in Japan is rated as among the lowest in Asia. Many Japanese women feel ashamed or are worried about being teased for speaking English or speaking it "too well", for fear others will consider them a "slut". Many Japanese women are overly paranoid about what others might be thinking.

This behavior of attacking interracial and international relationships by Japanese women, is highly backwards and disgraceful. Many foreigners don't realize the extent of it in Japan. Such Japanese will attack and smear foreign guys behind their back without reason. They don't know the person and have no reason for it. Many foreigners won't realize it, because they aren't fluent in Japanese, so aren't aware of the uncalled for attacks or negative comments.

And if such assholes aren't backstabbing random foreign guys, they can be trying to "slut shame" the Japanese women for having a date with foreigners or even talking English well.
 
This is a myth. Of the 16 Asian countries ranked in the EF English Proficiency Index, Japan is number 6.

http://www.prnewswire.com/news-rele...obal-ranking-of-english-skills-539730692.html

Moreover, this is presumably a rating for the country overall; there is more and better English proficiency in Tokyo than elsewhere in Japan.

As an aside, I was surprised not to see the UK on the list. Despite their weird accents, the Brits mostly speak English pretty well...about the same level as the Germans imo. :D

-Ww
 
@Solong but it all begs a question :-

Why these women can't think for themselves?! What breeds this mindset? Is it the culture of oppressing women in Japan that contributes to this?

There seem to be a pattern emerging: A Japanese woman goes abroad, learns that she actually can think for herself and have an opinion, and that people abroad and not tree-climbing savages; then comes back and cannot ever (most likely) re-integrate with the old ways that she now rejects.

As for the bartender... it's nothing, really. The things that Japanese guys (especially men are such a dedicated back-stabbers; quite outrageous, in fact) say about foreigners in my office.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lennylenny
This is a myth. Of the 16 Asian countries ranked in the EF English Proficiency Index, Japan is number 6.

http://www.prnewswire.com/news-rele...obal-ranking-of-english-skills-539730692.html
images


In TOEFL scores for English, Japan ranks at the bottom. So NOT a myth.

Stop trying to be a Japan apologist and defender, whenever you think or hear somebody is saying something negative about Japan or that Japan isn't a perfect place.

images
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
In TOEFL scores for English, Japan ranks at the bottom. So NOT a myth.

Actually, the English Proficiency Index results were borne out by a British Council backed tightly controlled study, and are held up as an indictment of how poor a job both the TOEFL and TOEIC exams do at determining English language ability.

Stop trying to be a Japan apologist and defender, whenever you think or hear somebody is saying negative about Japan or that Japan isn't a perfect place.

No need for the nastiness. My response to you, though contrary to your expressed opinion, was perfectly civil.

Anyway, back to the topic at hand...
 
Solong I like going out with ladies (a few at a time) & bringing them to nice places. I'm pretty aware of guys who believe they can roll up & take your lady.
I never pretend anything to give anyone a chance to throw dirt in any language gaijin, Japanese whatever.
My reasons for asking someone out isn't always about sex. I like getting wasted with ladies I can trust, so I also have a bit of a responsibility to them for getting them so wasted.
 
I think a lot of white people have never experienced much animosity simply for existing, so they come to Japan, experience relatively mild antagonism (compared to what happens elsewhere) and whine and moan about how racist Japanese people are. Sure, they can be a bit xenophobic but compared to what you'd get back home (depending on the country) if you're non-white it's nothing, trust me. If anything, use it to consider how much privilege and status you have nearly everywhere in the world and be grateful for that. To me it always seems comically overblown compared to what happens everywhere else to minorities
 
Actually, the English Proficiency Index results were borne out by a British Council backed tightly controlled study, and are held up as an indictment of how poor a job both the TOEFL and TOEIC exams do at determining English language ability.



No need for the nastiness. My response to you, though contrary to your expressed opinion, was perfectly civil.

Anyway, back to the topic at hand...
But your contrary opinion, is arguably an issue of why Japanese behavior and attitudes towards foreigners get bypassed.

You dismissed my opinion as if a myth, and then dismissed the TOEFL and TOEIC as if irrelevant exams (and they aren't). Like as if an opinion contrary to the narrative of Japan as "perfect place" or that Japan is not doing well at something, must be just the imagination of foreigners.

Furthermore, I have lived in Japan for many years and traveled to and lived in other Asian countries. What I'm saying isn't something based on lack of experience or a superficial observation. It's something that I have seen repeatedly in Japan. To include comparative English abilities between Asian countries, treatment of foreigners, and the dating scene in various countries of Asia.
 
Last edited:
@Solong but it all begs a question :-

Why these women can't think for themselves?! What breeds this mindset? Is it the culture of oppressing women in Japan that contributes to this?

I do think it's a form of subtle oppression against women. Instead of overt intimidation and threats, like among racists in some countries. Here, they tend to attempt to scare the women or make them feel uncomfortable.

It's an equally insidious and low tactic. The person pretends that it's done for her "protection", but instead has everything to do with bias, racism, and xenophobia. They won't allow her to think or choose freely. They scare her into making the choice that they want.

"I met a Spanish guy at Tsutaya on Friday."

"Oh no. You must watch out for those Spanish people. I hear they will steal your money or rape you. They come to Japan and cause crime. You must be careful of them. "

"I didn't know that. Thank you. I will block him in my e-mail."

"You are welcome [emoji83] "
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Black Mage
Using average TOEIC score as a basis for comparing nations English ability is nonsense.

In most countries on Solong's list only the rich elite take the test. In Japan every Tom, Dick and Harry take the test. So of course the average score will be lower. You are comparing apples with oranges.

Solong do you have a list of the number of test takers per country?
 
But your contrary opinion, is arguably an issue of why Japanese behavior and attitudes towards foreigners get bypassed.

I fail to see how my opinion of English language testing standards and overall regional ability correlates to your perception of racially based persecution.

You dismissed my opinion as if a myth, and then dismissed the TOEFL and TOEIC as if irrelevant exams (and they aren't).

They're only relevant because some companies and institutions use them as benchmarks. They are horribly poorly structured examinations, which is precisely why there is such an industry around specific preparation for them - they are as accurate in determining language ability as the Japanese driving exam is for determining driving skill. All they indicate is your ability to take and pass a specific test.

Like as if an opinion contrary to the narrative of Japan as "perfect place" or that Japan is not doing well at something, must be just the imagination of foreigners.

I did not say anything of the sort. Japan has its problems and shortcomings. Ocasionally, I disagree with you as to the nature of or what constitutes a shortcoming. I'm sure I also see other areas where Japan falls short in my opinion that you may not agree are shortcomings.

Furthermore, I have lived in Japan for many years and traveled to and lived in other Asian countries. What I'm saying isn't something based on lack of experience or a superficial observation. It's something that I have seen repeatedly in Japan. To include comparative English abilities between Asian countries, treatment of foreigners, and the dating scene in various countries of Asia.

Your length of time spent in Japan and Asia is hardly unique to you, Solong. Many of us on TAG are old Asia hands.

My observations overlap with yours in some areas, and diverge in others. This is natural, as we run in different social circles and have different occupations, thus we are bound to have a different experience of the region, and are also more or less likely to be up to date on certain matters.

The fact that our opinions differ in some areas does not mean I hold you in less regard. As a wiser man than I once said, when two people agree on everything, one of them isn't necessary.

I honestly think it would be fun to sit down with you over a beer and hash out a few of these topics, it would make for an interesting discussion.
 
Using average TOEIC score as a basis for comparing nations English ability is nonsense.

In most countries on Solong's list only the rich elite take the test. In Japan every Tom, Dick and Harry take the test. So of course the average score will be lower. You are comparing apples with oranges.

Solong do you have a list of the number of test takers per country?
I'm not going to side-track or derail down that path. My point was more the notion that Japanese speaking English poorly is a myth, where TOEFL and TOEIC say otherwise. Nor do I believe anybody here is qualified to dismiss those world recognized tests as irrelevant.

Besides that, I live in Japan and talk to Japanese here every day. In addition to traveling to neighboring Asian countries and speaking to Asians from other countries living in Japan. The difference in English ability is significant. And it's not just the English ability. It's the astounding number of Japanese that don't associate with foreigners and have no foreign friends.

The issue I originally brought up is Japanese feeling embarrassed and ashamed to speak English or being labeled "sluts" and "whores" because they can speak English well. This labeling has a side purpose of attacking any international or interracial relationships by close-minded xenophobics.
 
Last edited:
Not going to comment on the main point, as I'm not going to get into another argument about racism with you, but you are definitely showing bias here stating Japan is the bottom in Asia, from your link

Japan did rank ahead of Thailand, Vietnam, Mongolia, Macao, United Arab Emirates, Indonesia, Chile and last-place Albania.

I'm pretty sure your geography is better than to state that Thailand, Vietnam, Mongolia and Indonesia are not in Asia.
 
So long, just as a matter of interest, how is your Japanese?

In my experience a lot of people who share your feeling that the Japanese are in some way inclined towards racism, and this particularly sneaky type of racism that you mention, tend to have pretty poor japanese. For that reason I usually dismiss these sorts of arguments because of the wide scope for misunderstanding, and because nothing like this has ever happened to me in the several years that I have live here. But then my Japanese is pretty crappy so maybe I am just blithely unaware of all the racist interference that Japanese people are running on me behind my back.

I'd be interested to know.

Edit (because of mobile input problems again): also, your story sound awful. Terrible behavior. But also yeah encouraging that the other woman helped you out.
 
They're only relevant because some companies and institutions use them as benchmarks. They are horribly poorly structured examinations, which is precisely why there is such an industry around specific preparation for them - they are as accurate in determining language ability as the Japanese driving exam is for determining driving skill. All they indicate is your ability to take and pass a specific test.

Many job recruiters will tell you there is a strong correlation between high TOEFL and TOEIC scores, and speaking English well.

Now are there exceptions, like a fluent speaker that never took the TOEFL or TOEIC? Yes, have met them. However, many of those grew or spent significant time abroad, or are usually very international minded types.

My point is that many Japanese arguably do speak English poorly in comparison to other Asian countries isn't such a myth, as if not grounded in reality. That was the only point of me bringing up TOEFL and TOEIC, to show there is some basis to the argument.
 
Solong do you have a list of the number of test takers per country?
80% of test takers are in Japan and Korea, with about 2m from each country taking the test annually. The other 1 million people is spread across every other country in the world, so yes, just going on the test results alone is a really poor way of measuring a countries English ability, as no other country is as interested in measuring their scores as KR and JP. The fact that the scores are also low in high school students also drags down their percentage overall.

I'm not sure what TOEIC scores has to do with anything though. if anything, the fact so many people take the tests should be a positive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AliceInWonderland
Not going to comment on the main point, as I'm not going to get into another argument about racism with you, but you are definitely showing bias here stating Japan is the bottom in Asia, from your link

Japan did rank ahead of Thailand, Vietnam, Mongolia, Macao, United Arab Emirates, Indonesia, Chile and last-place Albania.

I'm pretty sure your geography is better than to state that Thailand, Vietnam, Mongolia and Indonesia are not in Asia.

Vietnam, Thailand, and Indonesia have done better than Japan on various TOEFL and TOEIC tests. Depends on what year and which test. Considering Japan's economic ranking, it's even more amazing they do so poorly.

My original point was more on the environment of Japanese women that do speak English well being "slut shamed" for it by xenophobic or racist associates.
 
In most countries on Solong's list only the rich elite take the test.

Not to mention that (to my knowledge) the first 6 countries on the Asia list have English as an official language.

It's particularly fascinating to me that a PUA is calling a guy who cockblocked him is 'sly' and 'cowardly' while he merely shrugs when PUAs actively pick up a girl that came to an establishment with another guy. You didn't own your date. Is it the cockblocking that bothers you that much, or merely the method of cockblocking?