Guest viewing is limited

Suggestion Reviewer top list

Cinnabums

Cinnabums

Pussy Connoisseur
Contributor License
Joined
Aug 17, 2022
Messages
4,423
Reaction score
10,778
With some members contributing at different levels a list of which members contributed the most reviews under each subsection would be fun and also triggering for some to actually put their experiences in print. I for one would always like to be among the top 3 contributors!

Would this be doable or is it difficult function no one else would use?
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura and Alice
Cinnabums said:
With some members contributing at different levels a list of which members contributed the most reviews under each subsection would be fun and also triggering for some to actually put their experiences in print. I for one would always like to be among the top 3 contributors!

Would this be doable or is it difficult function no one else would use?
Click to expand...
I'm afraid this would provoke people into writing reviews of lesser quality just to get the numbers up. We plan to add an additional tab to member profiles so they can visibly see how many reviews they have submitted. Making a ranking for overall reviews submitted, may have unintended consequences.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, just4fun, Simonka and 10 others
Alice said:
You just want it because you would be on to of the list. 😂
Click to expand...
Me? Really;)

TAG Manager said:
I'm afraid this would provoke people into writing reviews of lesser quality just to get the numbers up. We plan to add an additional tab to member profiles so they can visibly see how many reviews they have submitted. Making a ranking for overall reviews submitted, may have unintended consequences.
Click to expand...
Makes sense, I do have a number sessions I could share that could be useful to some but sometimes motivation is down and I am sure my early January encounters possibly would mean a poorer quality, thanks!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura and Alice
As of 2/8/2023 (and probably some reviews are counted that aren't approved yet)

Position​
Name​
Count​
1​
ah toh108
2Sudsy45
3mawjav41
4requiemmorrow37
5Tabanico36
6Cinnabums35
7User#783234
8​
SugoiBoy34
9alexleaud34
10kitsune30
11lotus29
12TheScientist29
13Durg5029
14nihonzuki29
15WarMonkey28
16One Pop23
17iamyuu23
18Danbo23
19AlexWand22
20Ken4fb22
21loulou_fisher21
22lonegaijin21
23DireWolf9821
24ur1987721
25Out of action20
26scorpioni6ths20
27MikeH20
28ichigopantsu19
29RightOn697518
30Intmaintokyo18
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, Majestyk, Discr and 10 others
Danbo said:
Thats quite a lead 🤣
Click to expand...
Quiet some handicap there though. Some have been writing for several years and some less than 6 months😉.

Danbo, I imagine you end up quiet high on that list too if looking at the last 6 months.

Funny fact, some of Ah Tohs 6 year old(Sora - Hisho etc) Yoshiwara reviews still has the girls working the same shops, great indeed!
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura and Alice
Cinnabums said:
Quiet some handicap there though. Some have been writing for several years and some less than 6 months😉.

Danbo, I imagine you end up quiet high on that list too if looking at the last 6 months.
Click to expand...

Nah, I don't care about that too much. I just don't write that many reviews. From time to time if a shop was never reviewed before, because that makes it easier for others to find info about it or maybe if a girl sticks out for whatever reason. I am not good at writing super exciting reviews anyway 😉

Cinnabums said:
Funny fact, some of Ah Tohs 6 year old(Sora - Hisho etc) Yoshiwara reviews still has the girls working the same shops, great indeed!
Click to expand...

The less funnier fact is that they most probably still have the same age in their profile like 6 years ago 😅
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, chacha23 and Alice
Cinnabums said:
With some members contributing at different levels a list of which members contributed the most reviews under each subsection would be fun and also triggering for some to actually put their experiences in print. I for one would always like to be among the top 3 contributors!

Would this be doable or is it difficult function no one else would use?
Click to expand...
I actually like the idea of a set of badges - one for each review section. Get one for each section you've posted a review in.

Independent Japan Escorts
1675849786742.png

Soapland
1675849817574.png

Escort Service
1675849855895.png

Esute/PS/Massage
1675849936414.png

BDSM
1675849977171.png

Trans
1675849996251.png

International
1675850022513.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, Danbo, Hana Maria and 8 others
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura and Alice
I'm a once a week guy now not counting AMPs though I've got hundreds of sessions built up over the decades. Probably could crack the top twenty given time and inclination, but I've little interest reviewing providers at AMPs so it'd take a bit.

That said, an official list is a bd idea but something fun like this to talk about is harmless. As others say, its less useful reviewing a bunch of providers from the same shop than to get reviews of new places and how receptive they can be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, SugoiBoy, steamboat bill jr and 1 other person
Cinnabums said:
Both agree and disagree since some shops have providers that are mostly great and other shops have a mish mash of pros and amateurs.

If said shop has reviews of 10 girls and 8 or 9 are positive its more likely to find a winner there. Some shops do weed out the weak(as horrible as it might sound).

This also depends on who the review is written for, is it for a tourist visiting Japan or is it for someone who lives here and speak the language?

The number is not important but it is important that people continue to write reviews.

A system with badges like listed above would be great and if they changed colour at lets say 1, 10, 25 and 50, even greater.
Click to expand...

Yeah, most important thing is that people continue to write reviews. They work in many different ways, because people also have very different preferences....you for example made it sound like amateurs are a bad thing. If somebody is looking for his first soapland experience this of course true, but I really like soaplands with a mishmash better 😅 Good thing is that it doesn't matter when reading the review because there is value for everyone.

As long as the reviews not only consist of a few sentences there can't be too many. The more reviews can be read for reference, the less problems in the long run 👍
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alice
Danbo said:
The less funnier fact is that they most probably still have the same age in their profile like 6 years ago 😅
Click to expand...
Yoshiwara age exists so it's up to everyone to do their homework.
I would rather laugh at those not doing their homework.
Sudsy said:
BDSM
1675849977171.png

Trans
1675849996251.png
Click to expand...
Thanks, I need that final push and what could be more motivating than a badge❤️
YokoMonger said:
As others say, its less useful reviewing a bunch of providers from the same shop than to get reviews of new places and how receptive they can be.
Click to expand...
Both agree and disagree since some shops have providers that are mostly great and other shops have a mish mash of pros and amateurs.

If said shop has reviews of 10 girls and 8 or 9 are positive its more likely to find a winner there. Some shops do weed out the weak(as horrible as it might sound).

The difference between the good and the bad is monumental at cheap Pink Salons like Kawasaki Toy Box so reviews of 10 of their girls really make a difference.

This also depends on who the review is written for, is it for a tourist visiting Japan or is it for someone who lives here and speak the language?

The number is not important but it is important that people continue to write reviews.

A system with badges like listed above would be great and if they changed colour at lets say 1, 10, 25 and 50, even greater.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, Alice and Danbo
Sudsy said:
I actually like the idea of a set of badges - one for each review section. Get one for each section you've posted a review in.

Independent Japan Escorts
View attachment 20380
Soapland
View attachment 20381
Escort Service
View attachment 20382
Esute/PS/Massage
View attachment 20383
BDSM
View attachment 20384
Trans
View attachment 20385
International
View attachment 20386
Click to expand...
Ken4fb said:
Cool, let's do hotel and condom review badge too.
View attachment 20388

View attachment 20379
Click to expand...
We can even get these made irl and have a presentation ceremony. Bit of ‘Eyes Wide Shut’ meets the Boy Scouts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cinnabums and Alice
TAG Manager said:
As of 2/8/2023 (and probably some reviews are counted that aren't approved yet)

Position​
Name​
Count​
1​
ah toh108
2Sudsy45
3mawjav41
4requiemmorrow37
5Tabanico36
6Cinnabums35
7User#783234
8​
SugoiBoy34
9alexleaud34
10kitsune30
11lotus29
12TheScientist29
13Durg5029
14nihonzuki29
15WarMonkey28
16One Pop23
17iamyuu23
18Danbo23
19AlexWand22
20Ken4fb22
21loulou_fisher21
22lonegaijin21
23DireWolf9821
24ur1987721
25Out of action20
26scorpioni6ths20
27MikeH20
28ichigopantsu19
29RightOn697518
30Intmaintokyo18
Click to expand...

The funny/sad thing is that if I included some recent experiences that I have to keep under wraps I would have likely written 25 new reviews by now.

Will be putting two more in the queue soon though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, Cinnabums and Danbo
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: uchimura, Airnest, hrbb and 1 other person
requiemmorrow said:
The funny/sad thing is that if I included some recent experiences that I have to keep under wraps I would have likely written 25 new reviews by now.

Will be putting two more in the queue soon though.
Click to expand...
Also have 8 sessions that won't see the light of day for different reasons such a under the radar indy, retired girl, scary skank, little plum etc..
But it didn't happen..

No review - it didn't happen❤️
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: uchimura, Airnest and requiemmorrow
requiemmorrow said:
The funny/sad thing is that if I included some recent experiences that I have to keep under wraps I would have likely written 25 new reviews by now.

Will be putting two more in the queue soon though.
Click to expand...

Yeah, but I think that is true for everyone. Some reviews are just not fit for the public board or you would have to leave stuff out which would also make it a bit pointless.

.....and if stores are well reviewed I also often have less motivation to write something. Feels like there is not much to add. At the moment there is a good stream of reviews each week which is nice.

Will try to book more new shops in the upcoming weeks to have more motivation to write about it 😉
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tkoadventure and SugoiBoy
You must log in or register to reply here.