I'd say it is a really tough/problematic topic, which I've seen much debated on other boards (but don't recall previous TAG discussions). Here's a bunch of somewhat disconnected comments:
- I do NOT think that the escort automatically deserves her full fee if a customer cancels. It is true that she *might* have given up another date and thus deserve compensation for that "opportunity cost", but then again she might not have had another one...so 100% compensation seems hard to justify logically, should be some fraction of the fee she would have received for the canceled date it seems to me. And of course there are other factors, especially how far in advance the date is canceled; it could be an hour or a week, giving her different chances of getting another date instead. And the night or day of the week is relevant to the "opportunity cost"; having a date canceled for a Friday night is a bit different than having one canceled for a Tuesday morning in terms of opportunity cost. Etc.
- And what compensation should a customer get when an escort cancels (or no-shows)? He has also lost an opportunity, sometimes a rare and precious one for traveling mongers. Should he get a discount on his next session with the provider or extra time or anything? Ime, most escorts do not offer anything more than an apology when they cancel, and this of course reduces the willingness of customers to pay any cancelation fee when they are the one to call it off (although it is usually with a different provider).
- Another negative of "penalties" for cancelations is that they may inhibit an escort or a customer from canceling even when there is a good and legit reason. Maybe he or she feels an oncoming sore throat, fever or cold and does not want to give it to their partner of the night. Maybe a bad review of her is posted after he makes the appointment. Maybe his name gets added to a black list by some other provider. Maybe one of them gets "a bad feeling" about the other due to something a bit creepy in a last minute correspondence. Etc.
- If everyone were honorable and acted in good faith, I think that cancelations would be rare and justified enough that it would make sense to forget about fees and penalties and simply accept them as a normal part of life. Sometimes something unexpected comes up in all of our lives. People get sick or have emergencies at work or home etc. Everyone should just apologize when it happens, and their apologies should be accepted. Of course but unfortunately, there are quite a lot of customers and escorts who do not behave so well and essentially take advantage of the fact that they can cancel with little consequence and do so for their own convenience. There are customers who routinely book multiple appointments well in advance for the night they are in town or free or whatever with the full intention of canceling all but one, or even all, of them when the time comes depending on their mood/whim or how heavy their wallet is or whatever. There are escorts who habitually cancel dates to take more lucrative ones (or ones with favorites) that come along at the last minute...or cancel just because they don't happen to feel like working when the time comes. It is these badly behaving people that make cancelations and no shows such a hassle for everyone else, and of course those that pay the cancelation fees and penalties are almost always the good behaving ones, not the problem causing ones. In other words, the fees and penalties tend to punish the blameless and do nothing to the unscrupulous.
- Old Man Note: These problems were A LOT worse before commercial sex went online. Without reviews or black lists, escorts and customers could cancel and no show with almost no consequence. I don't really know, but I wouldn't be surprised if such unhappy outcomes were 5 times more common in the pre-net p4p days.
- Except in the most extreme circumstances no-shows are hard to excuse or understand, but of course no shows are also the cases in which it is most difficult/impossible to collect any cancelation fee or penalty.
Overall, it is a mess with no real "solution" or "best practice" in sight as far as I can see.
-Ww